Four Bodies in Three Weeks

By Richard Pithouse · 20 Jan 2014

A+ A= A-
    Print this page       comments
Picture: Defence Web
Picture: Defence Web

Jan Rivombo. Mike Tshele. Osia Rahube. Lerato Seema.

Here we are, not even a month into the new year, and the police have already killed four unarmed people during protests.

Jan Rivombo sold fruit on the streets of Pretoria. He was killed by the police on Bosman Street as street traders tried to defend their livelihoods against an increasingly brutal and predatory state. He was a young man who had been a father for three months. He was not the first person to be killed by the state in its on-going attempt to drive poor people off the streets of our cities. It would be naïve, culpably naïve, to imagine that he will be the last.

Mike Tshele, Osia Rahube and Lerato Seema were killed at a protest in Mothutlung, Brits, during a protest demanding the restoration of the water supply. A resident, Chris Sebea, told a newspaper that they were ‘armed only with songs’. Mike Tshele was a photographer in his early sixties. He was a well-known figure in the area who moved around on an old bicycle. He was taking pictures when he was killed. Residents say that his camera was taken after he was killed. Osia Rahube was known as ‘Mokokotelo’ to his neighbours and friends. He was working, on contract, at an opencast mine at Marikana. He had been an activist and was a Christian. Lerato Seema was an engineering student. He played guitar in his church.

It has been reported that in a recent audit the local municipality was unable to account for around R1-billion in assets. The usual allegations of corruption and patronage abound.

When Nathi Mthethwa arrived to offer the usual pieties he was booed and sworn at. When Julius Malema arrived with a legal arsenal and an offer to help with the funeral costs he was received with considerably more warmth.

While the state was killing people asking for the most basic rights, popular mobilisation was moving in equally grim directions. In Durban two crudely anti-Indian organisations, both seeking to exploit popular suffering to advance elite interests, were speaking the language of the kind of nationalism that descends into fascism. Up the road in Pietermaritzburg a mob, said to be four hundred strong, gathered in the Ash Road settlement and hounded everyone they deemed not be South African out of the settlement beating people and looting their homes and businesses as they went. This settlement has been run, for years, by a well-known local shack lord with an IFP history and gangster connections who extracts rent, enforces obedience to shifting array of local politicians and uses thuggery to prevent independent organisation.

A few days before the xenophobic attack in Pietermaritzburg land occupations, in Durban and Cape Town, both named Marikana, were subject to unlawful evictions at the hands of armed men sent out by local municipalities. In both cities politicians, and others, have presented the presence of the people from the Eastern Cape in their cities in pathological terms. In both cities the language of ‘zero tolerance’, and the state violence that inevitably undergirds it, has been mobilised without regard for either the letter of the law or the grace and elegance of some of our jurisprudence.

Last week fraud charges against Shauwn Mpisane, the tenderpreneur who has made most of her fortune from the housing budget in Durban, were withdrawn after the state failed to present any evidence to the court. In the same city no one has been arrested for the murder last year of three activists in Cato Manor, where opposition to corruption has been at the heart of recent protests.

The ANC’s manifesto for the coming election is framed in a very different language to the crudities that we’ve come to expect from people like Blade Nzimande, Marius Fransman and, of course, Number One himself. It promises that the party will ‘Intensify the fight against corruption’ and develop ‘participatory democracy’ in the ‘new and far-reaching phase’ of our ‘democratic transition’. These words must be weighed against the lives of Jan Rivombo, Mike Tshele, Osia Rahube and Lerato Seema. They must be weighed against the impunity with which people with the right connections can loot the state. They must be weighed against the violent destruction of people’s homes, whether by the state or a xenophobic mob. The logic of that calculus is as clear as the scarlet brightness of blood pooling on a dusty street.

The ANC is not entirely rotten. Pallo Jordan is light years ahead of any other politician in terms of his personal contribution to our national debate. Aaron Motsoaledi might not be able to successfully take on the predatory interests that have captured the health system in the Eastern Cape but he’s certainly taken an impressively strong and principled position against the multinational pharmaceutical companies that are trying to enclose medical knowledge for private profit. Trevor Manuel’s commitment to the economic arrangements that have devastated our society is inexcusable. But he does have the merit of being willing to speak out against some of the excesses of the self-serving and sometimes simply poisonous cant that increasingly characterises the ANC’s contribution to our public sphere. But people like Jordan, Motsoaledi and Manuel are the exceptions that justify the rule. And in situations like these there is always a point, usually imprecise without the benefit of hindsight, at which holding out for better days as the rot spreads starts to shade into unintended complicity. The plain fact of the matter is that the party is rotten at its core. It continues to attract the support of many good people but bitter experience has shown that its constant assurances of a return to its highest ideals cannot be trusted.

In 2014 loyalty to the idea of the ANC, to what it has stood for in the past, and to what it has meant to people, can be an entirely decent political position. But that ANC is well lost. Loyalty to the party as it actually exists is a form of complicity with the accumulation of bodies at the hands of an increasingly predatory state.

Dr. Pithouse teaches politics at Rhodes University.

Should you wish to republish this SACSIS article, please attribute the author and cite The South African Civil Society Information Service as its source.

All of SACSIS' originally produced articles, videos, podcasts and transcripts are licensed under a Creative Commons license. For more information about our Copyright Policy, please click here.

To receive an email notification when a new SACSIS article is published, please click here.

For regular and timely updates of new SACSIS articles, you can also follow us on Twitter @SACSIS_News and/or become a SACSIS fan on Facebook.

You can find this page online at

A+ A= A-
    Print this page       comments

Leave A Comment

Posts by unregistered readers are moderated. Posts by registered readers are published immediately. Why wait? Register now or log in!


20 Jan

It's Now 5 Bodies In 3 Weeks

Its just been reported that a 5th person has died in Brits.

Respond to this comment

21 Jan

It's Now 6 Bodies

Just seen a report on IOL about a homeless person killed in the Durban CBD during an eviction of people sleeping rough in the city centre.

23 Jan

It's Now 7

7 protestors killed in the first month of the year.

We have a serious serious problem.

25 Jan


Seven protesters killed in the first month of the of the year! This is seriously outrageous.

Marikana was no aberration. Zuma is running a police state. He has to go, and fast.

Rory Verified user
24 Jan

Voter Dissatisfaction

"In 2014 loyalty to the idea of the ANC, to what it has stood for in the past, and to what it has meant to people, can be an entirely decent political position. But that ANC is well lost. Loyalty to the party as it actually exists is a form of complicity with the accumulation of bodies at the hands of an increasingly predatory state."

I agree completely as do, I think, many 'dyed in the wool' ANC supporters. However many of such people feel unable to vote for any other political party than the ANC and as a consequence are not going to register or visit a polling station at all. This is a sub-optimal response to their dissatisfactions and in fact is a betrayal of all those who struggled for the universal franchise in our country. They should still register and enter the polling station and once there ,spoil their ballot papers. This action is still a vote but not a vote for any particular political party, what it says is, no current political party is acceptable to me, the voter.

Respond to this comment

26 Jan

South Africa Has Become a Police State under Zuma

There is a very useful Wikipedia entry here:

It lists, with citations to newspaper reports, numbers of people reported to have been killed by the police on protests.

The killings start in 2000 and are escalating dramatically. I have extracted the numbers per year - see below.

2000 - 1
2004 - 3
2005 - 1
2006 - 1
2008 - 2
2009 - 2
2010 - 3
2011 - 9
2012 - 5 + 34 at Marikana = 39
2013 - 12
2014 - 6 (at the end of January)

Respond to this comment

27 Jan

And One More Body......